Utopia (Robinson translation)
Gelesen von Ruth Golding
Thomas More
(4,59 Sterne; 39 Bewertungen)
Originally entitled A frutefull pleasaunt, and wittie worke of the beste state of publique weale, & of the newe yle, called Utopia: written in Latine, by ... Syr Thomas More knyght, and translated into Englishe by Raphe Robynson ...
The first book tells of the traveller Raphael Hythloday, to whom More is introduced in Antwerp. The second book consists of Hythloday's description of the island and people of Utopia, their customs, laws, religions, economy, language and relations with other nations. Hythloday portrays Utopia as an idealised state, where all property is common to all the people and money does not exist within its bounds, thus, he argues, removing all poverty, hunger and fear, and most criminal acts. More himself appears unconvinced by some of his narrator's arguments.
This is recorded from a reprint of the 1556 Robinson translation, with a foreword by William Morris. (Summary by Ruth Golding) (6 hr 3 min)
Chapters
Bewertungen
Beautiful, memorable, unique, imaginative book.
Connor Dykes
(5 Sterne)
It's remarkable how detailed Saint Sir Thomas More was able to be w/ the isle's details. My understanding is this is the first work of conscious 'worldbuilding' fiction in history and so mythopoetic works like Tolkien's are in a kind of line of descent from it. I don't think More was sarcastic re: the goodness of Utopia as per the "conservative" reading of C.S. Lewis. The last section of Hythloday's talkk on money, was clearly critical of his own societies, and in the tale he even says he wishes rather than hopes for many of the things of Utopia to come to pass in Europe. I recommend Jason Blakely's hermenueitc on the book for ta nuanced reading (https://youtu.be/jiQKLNhppdl), More showing the dawning consciousness of our own partly contingent creation of society in his exploration of Utopia, whether or not it itself is meant as a perfect ideal (which I think it comes pretty close to, given nothing in this world can fully). The reader was lovely, giving a Victorian, refined yet ancient feel.
no apologetics necessary
Rhonda Wilmot
(4 Sterne)
let people get to know the utopia without apologetic explanation by a modern communist, socialist. The narration is great. In Victor Davis Hansons 'Who Killed Homer's, one realizes that an interpreter who puts his own ideas in the text has changed the text. Socialism and Communism delivers the same results....no matter what generation tries it out. My only beef with this book was the introduction by the translator.
A Sound Recording and competent presentation
Grimmly_Sands
(4 Sterne)
Ruth did a marvelous job reading and annunciating the ideas set out long ago by Sir Thomas More. It is. worthy listen for those inclined to what might have been and what might yet be.
Another must read
João Pinheiro
(5 Sterne)
It's the original utopia, similar to the one each one of us should try to build!